'You're pushing it, so be careful' War of words at Houston council over Prop B

HOUSTON, Texas (KTRK) -- Houston's city council meeting Wednesday was at times heated as the body heard, among other things, how it will contend with a $260 million budget shortfall for the next year.

Houston Mayor Sylvester Turner today initially said his administration already has a list of city employee layoffs to deal with the expected cost of Proposition B, the voter-approved measure mandating equal pay between firefighters and police officers. A short time after 13 Investigates requested the list under the Texas Public Information Act, Mayor Turner reversed course suggesting his administration is still coming up with the list. Turner would not say how long it is or if hundreds of firefighters are on it. He has previously suggested that many may be needed.

"If there are going to be any layoffs in question, I will tell you, we have identified who those layoffs will apply [sic]," Turner said during the meeting. "That list has been put together."

After the meeting, when questioned, Turner said there was no such list.

"Let me correct myself, as we finalize the process and the system and you put a cost on that, then you determine what we can afford, what we can't and how we then balance the budget."

RELATED: Fire union to Turner: It's past time to implement Prop B

It is the latest back and forth in the months-long process to implement the voter-approved measure. Today marks three months since Election Day when voters approved the measure.

Turner was tough to pin down on where negotiations stand. At one point Wednesday he said his administration has had meetings and conversations with the Firefighters Association about implementation. When pushed Turner clarified saying there have been no meetings, only "conversations" and admitted no proposals have been offered to the association representing firefighters.

The Houston Professional Firefighters Union tells us there have been no substantive conversations outside of the ongoing lawsuits between the union and city and none have been scheduled.

Turner claims there is a meeting scheduled, though when asked, he wouldn't give a date, only saying it would happen "soon."

Tomorrow night at 10, 13 Investigates takes you inside the HFD Academy where 23 cadets have been stuck in training since just after election day. Their training cost you hundreds of thousands and their deployment could save you money in overtime costs, but there's no movement. See what they've been doing since the mayor decided the trained lifesavers wouldn't be sworn in.

Houston city council members have also issued a 20-point memo to Turner, which points out ways to pay for the implementation of Proposition B.

The memo ranges from layoffs to privatizing garbage to EMS services.

Wednesday city controller Chris Brown paired the list with the city consultant's list.

The consultant's list offered nearly 60 cost-cutting measures. That report, which cost the city $565,000, has a number of suggestions that could streamline city operations Brown said.

The Prop B and finance discussion took up two-thirds of the meeting and became contentious at times between Turner and the council.

EMBED More News Videos

Several council members asked Turner for more inclusion and more planning time for the budget process.



Several council members asked Turner for more inclusion in the budget process and more planning time to better understand where the city's money will go.

"I'm hoping we have the opportunity to look at specifics on particular items as we move through the spring so we're not just handed a budget on May the first and told 'We want you to pass this on May 15," council member Mike Laster said.

"Council member, it's the same timeline as the last three years," Turner said.

"There wasn't much conversation," Laster said. "There wasn't."

EMBED More News Videos

Council members weigh options to pay for Prop B



"We shouldn't have to be begging for financial information," council member Dwight Boykins, said. "Don't treat us like children."

Turner snapped back at some of the council members, who said he was disrespecting them. Once, Turner seemed upset because Boykins didn't call him "Mayor" Turner.

"I respect Sylvester Turner," Boykins said.

"I'm the mayor," Turner rebutted. "My name is---"

"The mayor," Boykins interjected.

"Thank you," Turner said. "And you're really pushing it. So be careful."

"What can you do to me, Mayor?"

"This is not a dictatorship," Boykins said.

13 INVESTIGATES: Houston water testers accused of skipping sample sites, falsifying results


The list includes:

  • Implement recurring benefit changes recommended by Fire Chief Samuel Pena
  • Explore all enterprise funds for additional revenue that are not restricted by law or ordinance to apply to the implementation of Proposition B (one-time benefit)
  • Explore expediting and increasing reach of claw-back process for special revenue funds and further investigation of low hanging fruit (recurring and one-time benefit)
  • The city of Houston is required by law to keep 7.5% reserve funds on hand in the event of an emergency. Currently, the city of Houston has an estimated 8.9% funds in reserve, which amounts to approximately $83.5 million. It was suggested the excess reserves be utilized immediately to implement Proposition B (one-time benefit)
  • Phase in the implementation of Proposition B over 5 years (recurring benefit)
  • Currently if city Departments continue to spend at the same rate through the end of fiscal year 19, which ends in June 2019, there will be an estimated $88 million in surplus funds. It was suggested that the budget surplus be used to immediately implement Proposition B (one-time benefit)
  • Immediately begin the request for proposal process in preparation for managed competition in departments like solid waste management and emergency medical services (recurring benefit & PFM Report item)
  • Explore the options of privatization in the departments of solid waste management and emergency medical services (recurring benefit)
  • Increase employee contribution to monthly medical plan from current rate to 25% of total monthly cost (recurring benefit)
  • Implement a City of Houston garbage fee (recurring benefit)
  • Zero Based Budget (recurring benefit)
  • Equitable distribution of Capital Improvement Project Funds
  • Develop and implement a real estate strategy that calls for the creation of overarching guiding strategies associated with the acquisition and sale of city of Houston properties. This strategy in part would call for the leveraging of city assets for public-private partnerships
  • Review opportunities to collaborate with the county for ongoing maintenance and operations
  • Implement all findings contained within the November 2017 PFM Report immediately instead of phasing in over ten years (recurring benefit)
  • Layoff 950 Houston Firefighters
  • Add a monthly Firefighter fee to water bills (recurring benefit)
  • Cut Council District Service Funds to $5.5 million
  • Explore the option of furloughing city of Houston employees in lieu of layoffs
  • Research the legality of accessing restricted funds and restricted special revenue funds that have a surplus to immediately implement Proposition B


The decisions will be made over the coming weeks and months as the city prepares itself for the next fiscal year, which starts in July. The projected budget deficit is $260 million dollars, including $100 million for the Prop B implementation.

SEE MORE: Houston's Prop B: What now?

For the latest investigations, follow Ted on Facebook and Twitter.

Have a tip for Ted Oberg? A problem to solve? Get in touch with us on our tip page, or send a tip below. (On mobile? You can open our form by tapping here.)
Copyright © 2019 KTRK-TV. All Rights Reserved.