AJ Armstrong's 3rd capital murder trial underway after delays, 7 years after parents' deaths

Courtney Fischer Image
Monday, July 31, 2023
3rd AJ Armstrong murder trial opens with blood evidence in focus
A family saga that has unfolded for years continues for the third time in the courtroom. ABC13 was in court as opening statements got underway in the murder trial of AJ Armstrong.

HOUSTON, Texas (KTRK) -- Seven years and two days after Antonio Sr. and Dawn Armstrong were found shot to death in their southwest Houston home, their son, A.J. Armstrong, now 23, will face his third capital murder trial, charged with killing them.

The jury was picked two months ago, after three weeks of an intense, one-on-one interview process. Multiple sources close to the case are now confirming to ABC13 that one of those jurors is out, which means one of the four alternates will move up.

Of the 12 jurors expected to deliberate, there are six men and six women, ranging in age from 26 to 65.

The trial was delayed from June after experts discovered what's believed to be blood on Armstrong's gray T-shirt he was wearing the morning of the murders.

READ MORE: New evidence, likely blood, in AJ Armstrong's murder case, subject of postponed hearing, sources say

The hearing was supposed to decide if new evidence will be allowed in trial. Armstrong's T-shirt was retested after what appear to be flakes of blood were discovered under an HPD visitor's badge, sources say.

Antonio Sr. and Dawn were shot in their bedroom in the early morning hours of July 29, 2016. Dawn was shot twice in the head and was found dead when EMTs arrived. Investigators say Antonio Sr., shot once, was rushed to the hospital, where he later died.

Armstrong, who was 16 at that time, heading into his sophomore year at Lamar High School, was arrested and charged with capital murder.

Twice, juries could not agree on a verdict. In 2019 and again in 2022, a near three-week trial ended in a mistrial.

We expect prosecutors, for the third time, to work to show how the killer had to have come from inside the house, pointing to the alarm records. Armstrong's attorneys have argued those same records show glitches and can't be trusted.

SEE ALSO: From crime scene to courtroom: Courtney Fischer takes you inside the AJ Armstrong case

ABC13's Courtney Fischer opens up about her exclusive interview with Armstrong, who is accused of killing his parents.

Judge Kelli Johnson has decided no cameras will be allowed in court for Monday's opening statements, which is different than the two previous trials. No video or audio recordings will be allowed throughout the trial until closing statements.

Armstrong's trial is expected to last three weeks. For an in-depth conversation about the case, click here.

For news updates, follow Courtney Fischer on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram.

READ MORE: 7 years after his parents' murders, AJ Armstrong is about to be tried for the 3rd time

ABC13's Courtney Fischer takes you inside the AJ Armstrong case seven years after the murders of Dawn and Antonio Armstrong.