Gov. Greg Abbott says rape victims can take Plan B despite limited access for state's poorest people

ByWilliam Melhado, The Texas Tribune
Tuesday, September 6, 2022
Gov. Abbott says rape victims can take Plan B despite limited access
"Fundamental misunderstanding of of women's lives and our biology": Due to the healthcare landscape, accessing emergency contraception may not be feasible for low-income Texans.

On Friday, Gov. Greg Abbott told The Dallas Morning News that rape victims can take emergency contraception, like Plan B, to prevent a pregnancy. With abortion now banned in Texas, even in instances of incest or rape, the governor recommended the use of emergency contraception to ensure a victim of rape does not become pregnant.

But for the lowest-income people in Texas, emergency contraception isn't widely accessible, advocates said - a consequence of the significant number of people of childbearing age who are uninsured and the state's lack of programs that provide access to treatment like Plan B.

During a pre-recorded segment of Lone Star Politics, Abbott said of rape victims, "By accessing health care immediately, they can get the Plan B pill that can prevent a pregnancy from occurring in the first place. With regard to reporting it to law enforcement, that will ensure that the rapist will be arrested and prosecuted."

Emergency contraception primarily works by stopping fertilization. The treatment can prevent someone from becoming pregnant if taken up to five days after sex, with varying effectiveness.

In instances of rape, Abbott said, "We want to support those victims, but also those victims can access health care immediately, as well as to report it."

After signing Senate Bill 8 into law last September, which banned abortions after about six weeks of pregnancy and didn't provide exceptions for rape or incest, Abbott said the state's goal was to eliminate rape. Abbott's office did not return a request for comment on Saturday.

RELATED: Texas trigger law banning almost all abortions in effect now

The trigger law is now in effect, abortion, in most cases, now becomes a felony. Some say this puts providers in a more difficult position.

In 2020, Texas ranked 16th in the nation for total number of forcible rape cases per capita.

Emilee Whitehurst, the CEO of Houston Area Women's Center, said a significant number of rapes aren't reported, and the actual number of victims is higher than those that seek treatment at a hospital.

Whitehurst added that emergency contraception is not a substitute for abortion access in any way, but those responsible for the abortion ban in Texas have left victims of sexual assault with few options. She said it was insulting to hear that Plan B should be relied on to prevent pregnancies given the dangers victims of sexual assault already face.

"To presume Plan B could be a substitute for abortion care represents such a fundamental misunderstanding of the reality of women's lives and our biology," Whitehurst said.

While emergency contraception is available for purchase over the counter, it can cost $50 at a pharmacy. Some insurance plans cover the cost of emergency contraception, but those who are uninsured have to pick up that additional expense.

For women of childbearing age in Texas, more than a quarter had no health insurance in 2017 - the highest rate in the nation. This is caused, in part, because Texas has not expanded Medicaid and has one of the lowest eligibility standards in the country. A single parent with three children would have to earn less than $400 a month to qualify for Medicaid.

SEE ALSO: Houston mayor says abortion-related investigations are 'lowest priority'

Houston Mayor Sylvester Turner announced the city won't prioritize investing resources into seeking out violators of the state abortion ban.

In addition to the lack of coverage, the state's programs that target women's healthcare don't provide emergency contraception. Neither the Family Planning Program nor the Healthy Texas Women Program provide emergency contraception.

Title X clinics remain one of the few options for low-income people to access emergency contraception at an affordable cost. However, these federally-funded reproductive health clinics don't operate in every community in the state.

Whitehurst said that guaranteed access to emergency contraception is "fairytale thinking." She said young victims of sexual assault, in particular, will struggle to access that form of contraception.

"It is not easily available, it is not easily affordable, and it is an untenable resolution to the terrible situation women now find themselves in with no access to abortion," Whitehurst said.

In the instance of victims of rape, the immediate need to seek out emergency contraception compounds the trauma a survivor is already facing, said Chau Nguyen, a trauma therapist with JEM Wellness & Counseling in Houston. Nguyen said in a statement to The Texas Tribune that low-income Texans and women of color already face barriers to healthcare access, which includes emergency contraception.

"The sad truth is, women will choose putting food on the table to feed their kids over their own health care. And that can greatly put their own lives at risk," Nguyen said.

The Texas Tribune is a nonprofit, nonpartisan media organization that informs Texans - and engages with them - about public policy, politics, government and statewide issues.

RELATED:
'I had to carry my baby to bury my baby': Woman says she was denied abortion for fetus without skull

A Louisiana mother of three was told her baby would not develop a skull and die, yet providers denied her an abortion because of concerns it would violate the state's trigger laws.

Can adoption replace abortion? Experts say it's a lot more complicated than it sounds

Texas will ban all abortions from the moment of fertilization, starting 30 days after the ruling, with only a few, narrow exceptions. The law also criminalizes the person who performs the abortion.