US seeks court order requiring Texas to remove floating buoy barriers in Rio Grande

The string of buoys is a safety hazard that violates treaties and harms relations with Mexico, DOJ lawyers tell a federal judge.

ByOlivia Alafriz, The Texas Tribune
Thursday, July 27, 2023
US seeks court order requiring TX to remove floating barrier at border
The Justice Department filed paperwork on Wednesday asking a judge to order Texas Gov. Greg Abbott to have the floating barrier removed.

RIO GRANDE, Texas -- Arguing that Gov. Greg Abbott's floating barrier in the Rio Grande is a safety hazard that violates international treaties and harms relations with Mexico, the U.S. Justice Department asked a federal judge Wednesday to order Texas to remove the barrier within 10 days.

The department is also seeking an injunction blocking Texas from erecting future river barriers without prior approval from the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers.

"Texas's deployment of the Floating Barrier has caused significant and ongoing harm to the United States' foreign relations with Mexico," the filing said, adding that Mexican officials have raised their concerns "at the highest diplomatic levels."

"Mexico has specifically asserted that Texas's actions contravene various treaty obligations and has raised humanitarian concerns regarding possible loss of life to persons swimming in the Rio Grande," the filing said.

SEE ALSO: DOJ investigating reports Texas troopers told to push migrants back into Rio Grande, deny them water

The federal government asked Texas officials to remove the barrier on July 20, about 10 days after it was installed near Eagle Pass to deter migrants from crossing the river. Abbott refused, saying in a reply letter: "Texas will see you in court, Mr. President."

The Justice Department obliged, suing Texas in Austin federal court Monday, then following up Wednesday with a request for a court order requiring the barrier's removal.

The lawsuit argued that the barrier violated the Rivers and Harbors Act, which prohibits the obstruction of U.S. waterways, and was not approved by the bilateral International Boundary and Water Commission, as required by a 1970 treaty.

Other statements included within the filing raised specific concerns.

SEE MORE: 'See you in court': Gov. Greg Abbott responds to Biden Administration over border lawsuit

Gov. Greg Abbott dares the Biden Administration to take him to court over new barriers along the Rio Grande River on the Texas/Mexico border.

Hillary Quam, the U.S.-Mexico border coordinator for the U.S. State Department, said Mexican officials had protested the river barrier as a violation of treaties dating back to 1848.

"If the barrier is not removed expeditiously, its presence will have an adverse impact on U.S. foreign policy, including our relationship with the government of Mexico," Quam wrote in an affidavit accompanying the filing.

Mexico also has raised humanitarian concerns, she said.

"Mexico is concerned that individuals swimming in the river may get caught in the floating barrier and risk injury or even death. Such an injury ... could quickly rise to a significant international incident," Quam wrote.

Another affidavit from Jason Owens, chief of the U.S. Border Patrol, said the 39-mile stretch of river that includes the barrier is dangerous, requiring 249 water-related rescues, and resulting in 89 deaths since 2018.

"Any obstructions in the water could naturally impair the freedom of movement and potentially delay response times," Owens wrote.

Coast Guard officials also described potential threats to operations, citing a need to assess how the barrier could impact the navigability of the river.

The Texas Tribune is a nonprofit, nonpartisan media organization that informs Texans - and engages with them - about public policy, politics, government and statewide issues.