Executives on trial after allegedly putting employees at risk during Hurricane Harvey

Miya Shay Image
Thursday, February 27, 2020
Arkema trial begins after workers claim chemical exposure
EMBED <>More Videos

The Arkema chemical plant is having a trial after it released toxins into the air following Hurricane Harvey.

HOUSTON, Texas (KTRK) -- Opening statements were given on Thursday in the unusual criminal trial against Arkema chemical plant and its executives after chemicals were said to have combusted during Hurricane Harvey.

The French chemical company Arkema, its former Vice President of logistics Michael Keogh, CEO Richard Rowe, and Plant Manager Leslie Comardelle are all facing criminal charges.

Prosecutors accused Keogh of putting Harris County Sheriff's Office deputies in harms way by telling local emergency officials that Arkema had real-time data monitoring of the tanks that 350,000 gallons of organic peroxide, which they knew would explode when they reached a certain temperature.

"Chemical products, specifically peroxides, were exposed to rising water during Hurricane Harvey," said special prosecutor Mike Doyle during opening statements. "The choice these managers made, as Arkema always did, is to keep the product on the ground, in the threat of weather, every single time."

A spokesperson from Arkema allegedly told emergency personnel the company was keeping track of its chemicals with off-site, real-time monitoring and would notify emergency personnel before they would be at risk of exposure to toxic chemicals from the plant.

Prosecutors say the company resorted to asking its own workers to move the dangerous chemicals by hand, in barrels, as the waters rose around them.

The chemical release and fires shut down a mile and a half around the plant for days. At least 21 first responders and other officials were injured after they inhaled some of the fumes while arriving at the plant.

Attorneys for Arkema argued the company had a full hurricane plan in place, but nobody could have predicted the severity of Hurricane Harvey.

"No one knew how devastating Harvey was going to be on the city of Houston, no one," said Letitia Quinones. "Some people call Hurricane Harvey a 2,000-year-old flood. I suggest to you that's almost when Jesus was here, when something like that happened."

Attorney Tim Johnson, who is representing Rowe, made a similar line of attacks in his opening statements.

"There was no causation because Harvey was an act of God," Johnson said.

Turning to a slide of the Astrodome, he looked at the jurors, and said, "There was enough water to fill the Astrodome 3,200 times. Was that biblical?"

Ironically, the rest of the opening statements were cut short by Houston's latest flood. The water main break on the city's east side shut down the downtown courthouse complex around 3 p.m. on Thursday.

Opening arguments will resume on Monday.

Follow Miya Shay on Facebook and Twitter.

MORE ON ARKEMA TRIAL: New docs reveal more of DA's criminal case against Arkema

Arkema CEO, plant manager make first court appearance after indictments for Harvey response

Harris County DA announces new indictments for Arkema and its VP of Logistics