'God saved us': Family speaks out after nearly being crushed by tree in NYC

Michelle Charlesworth  Image
Thursday, March 20, 2025 9:50PM
Moment Falling Tree Narrowly Misses 3 People
The incident happened on 59th Street in the Bensonhurst neighborhood of south Brooklyn.

NEW YORK CITY -- A family in Brooklyn, New York, is sharing their story after their brush with death when a tree suddenly came crashing down behind them.

Just seconds before the tree came down, Shelly, Ben and Michael were talking about how old the tree looked.

"'Wow! Look at that tree, it's quite old.' And as we're getting under the tree, you start hearing cracking, and I finally got to the other side of the tree, and it was down," Ben Kerstein said.

It happened on Saturday around 4 p.m. Shelly, Ben and Shelly's brother Michael were on their way to a family gathering.

After the tree fell, video showed that the inside of it was hollow, and there was nothing but dust. The top of the tree had been cut off long ago.

"It was an older tree. It was super dead, but enough that if it had landed on us, we would've been dead," Ben Kerstein said.

The tree is gone now. The Parks Department told our sister station WABC-TV that the tree does not belong to them.

Ben and his wife, Shelly Kerstein, said it could have been worse.

"I just can't imagine the thought process if our kids had been a few feet, lagging behind us," Ben Kerstein said.

His wife says their kids could have been flattened if they had been with them.

But knowing all of this in that moment, Ben Kerstein saw cause for celebration and was caught on camera dancing just seconds after the tree came crashing down.

"There was no other way, God saved us. We had to celebrate, you know," he said.

His wife says she's not surprised and that it's just his instinct.

In the meantime, there was more craziness for Ben and Shelly on Wednesday.

"We got two flats on the expressway, but we're still dancing," Ben Kerstein said.

It's another reminder that we can't always control what happens to us, but we can control how we respond.

Copyright © 2025 WABC-TV. All Rights Reserved.