Video shows the man heaving a rock through the window of the store in February. He then climbed in the window and took the stuffed toy that was sitting on a white grand piano.
The store said a few pianos suffered minor damage in the break-in.
For now, the stolen Mickey has been replaced with a different stuffed Mickey, as well as a stuffed Minnie Mouse, given by a customer.
RELATED: Woman dashes to save son's plush Mickey Mouse on roadway